Search This Blog

Sunday, 13 May 2018

Anti Work Essays



A series of Audio essays by the group Audio Anarchy. The audio used for the videos can be downloaded here.

"Why do we work? From necessity or love? If the former, then our world is failing us, we are being exploited, being made slaves for the benefit of others. The ethic that work is a 'good thing' is a throwback to a Victorian mentality of puritanical pain and denial of our humanity, an ethic that is so far removed from the reality of our human nature as to be pathological."
A collection of essays written from the anti-work perspective. These essays investigate concepts of freedom, compulsory labor, the 'work ethic', the wages system, employment, and 'occupations.'

The play list.

Anti Work 101




An introduction to the concept of anti work, as despite the popularity of hating work the concept of abolition it all together often strikes a person as absurd on first hearing of it.

The Decline and Fall of Work



An excerpt from chapter 5 of the Revolution of everyday life by Raoul Vaneigem

The Tyranny of the Clock



The Tyranny of the Clock by George Woodcock

In Praise of Idleness 



An extract from Bertrand Russell's essay In Praise of Idleness.

The Abolition of Work




Thursday, 10 May 2018

Audio Anarchy in Memorium




A number of years ago when I was finishing up University I got curious about the many strands of left wing politics and the multitude of `isms. So I started exploring, buying cheap books on the history of revolts, essays and political texts. For anarchism an early source of information was a website called Audio Anarchy. Sadly Audio Anarchy has recently gone offline, the domain has expired and the links to the site and the downloads section now no longer work. Its not really surprising I have Audio Anarchy on my podcast apps and the last update was in 2006, so the people behind it gave it a lot of support. Maybe it'll be restored but I don't hold out hope. Fortunately though I was able to download all the recorded audio files via the wayback machine.

Audio Anarchy is a project for transcribing anarchist books into audio format.
Hopefully, this can help make anarchist texts and ideas more accessable. Beyond the obvious appeal for people who don't like to read (or don't have time to read in this busy on-the-go world), hearing a book read aloud can also be enjoyable.
The Audio Anarchy project is organized in a distributed way. Instead of having a single person or group of people read an entire book, different people read separate chapters to distribute the work load. Ideally, this site will do more to help facilitate that kind of organization in the future.

The group made seven albums, a selection of essays by Emma Goldman, a collection of short speeches called the Anarchist tension by Alfredo Bonanno, Against the Logic of Submission by Wolfi Landstreicher, Thoughts on Society of the Spectacle -which isn't a direct reading its a reading of a selection of passages from Guy Debord's Society of the Spectacle with the readers explaining what they read and giving some practical examples- Days of War, Nights of Love a publication by the American anarchist group Crimethinc. A selection of Anti work essays from several authors including George Woodcock, and the groups last production was Fredy Perlman's novel Letters of Insurgents.

They also developed a side project called Radio Anarchy, which was four original recordings by the group on several subjects, the history of the concept of property, a biographical recounting of Hitchhiking through the USA, a critique of democracy and technology.

Quite an impressive list to be honest, and quite useful. I made several of them into videos for YouTube and kept meaning to get around to the rest of them, its a good thing I did because it meant I kept checking on the site every once in a while.

The site lasted from 2002 until the winter of 2018, in its sixteen years of existence it had over a million overall downloads, but that number doesn't account for downloads via the torrents, Days of War Nights of Love was still active when I checked and I was able to kickstart several others with the audio files I downloaded, unfortunately some of the torrents used different version so unless another seed logs on they won't work. The group also sold CD's of their recordings so their reach extended even further.



Here's the files:

The master folder Media Fire (https://www.mediafire.com/#y53rhbmrad5rb)
Google doc folder

The Anarchist Tension
Thoughts on Society of the Spectacle
Anti Work Essays
Essays by Emma Goldman
Against the Logic of Submission
Days of War Nights of Love
Letters of Insurgents
Radio Anarchy

Thoughts on Society of the Spectacle

A selective reading from the Society of the Spectacle with elaboration and demonstrations of how the particular thesis's relate to the world and real life.



"The whole life of those societies in which modern conditions of production prevail presents itself as an immense accumulation of spectacles. All that once was directly lived has become mere representation." Instead of a direct recording of the text, here a collection of people read some of their favorite aphorisms, and tell stories about how those aphorisms relate to their lives.

The readings are taken from  the now defunct Audio Anarchy, the audio can no longer be downloaded from their website but copies of the audio can be downloaded here.

The text of Society of the Spectacle (SOS) can be found here. Though personally I recommend reading Guy Debord's follow up Comments on Society of the Spectacle first, Debord is a lot more clearer in that.

Sunday, 6 May 2018

Notes on Discourse - Whittakers Ear




I've been active in radical politics of various kinds online and offline for about 10 years now, and I've noticed some patterns in discussion that really aren't very good, I'd go so far as to say quite a bit of its counter productive and harmful to even the participants.

I'm just going to stress that I support and encourage reading, hell I'm actually an advocate of education and learning in all its many forms. I think the best way to support and teach ourselves and others is to cultivate a plurality of information sources, books, audio books, extracts, translations, films, lectures, discussions, practicals, music, games, even the much maligned powerpoint presentation. I think the source is usually best but an useful and faithful adaption can work wonders. I'm beginning to sense a bit of snobbery regarding methods and mediums of information, particular comics, movies and games.

In addition I've come to think that much of the discourse on the reading honestly has become a bit too ritualised and a substitute for other aspirations.

Read Blank, you have? well then obviously you haven't read Blank enough

One curious thing I've noticed is the prevalence of an attitude that honestly is a hang over liberal enlightenment. I know liberal is a loaded term to throw around in theses parts put its the same idea and strategy. Liberalism believed in a linear form of progress and the supremacy of reason so opposition must stem from ignorance, and the solution to ignorance is the consumption of more scriptures from the cult of reason.

Of course it didn't work out like that, two of Voltaire's biggest admirers were the Autocrats Frederick the Great of Prussia and Catherine the Great of Russia. And in general the popularity of enlightenment books and pamphlets lead to the creation of "benevolent" despotism of the Kings and Emperors of Europe.

So I really don't understand why so many people think it will work know.

To give just one example of this mindset I bring up the website readmarx.ml its a website set up to mock Marxist Leninists, Maoists, Third Worldists etc, and advocating reading from Marx instead. I personally don't like any of those tendencies either and prefer Marx to most alternatives from their schools of thought, but I don't think the author of the site has thought this through very much.

The selection of recommended reading throws up some issues, the popularity of Marx's writings is owed largely to the Soviet Union. I know that makes some people uncomfortable but its undeniable. Not only did the Soviet publishing houses keep his texts constantly in print in the 20th century, not only did they translate them into nearly every language they also published texts that Marx had never published before.

Gundrisse was first published in 1939 and the Economic and Philosophical manuscripts in 1932. And the Complete Works of Marx and Engels came to over 50 volumes. Indeed several of the texts Readmarx recommends link to translations by our friends Progress Publishers. Presumably this mammoth task did involve some reading and discussion. And yet, curiously the Soviet Union remained the Soviet Union, if it took any serious steps away from Marxism-Leninism it was towards European social democracy in the 1980s.

In addition one of the recommended works is Socialism: Utopian and Scientific, which was written by Engels who is not Karl Marx. This is an issue because its an admission that other people can have important contributions to Marxism, so why not others like Lenin who referred to Marx extensively in his writing. Or say someone who like to refer to Lenin a lot in his writing, like say Stalin?

Also if you'll permit me a bit of a tangent Engels Socialism: Utopian and Scientific is where dialectical materialism comes from. Anecdotally speaking Dialectical Materialism is a concept I heavily associate with the `immortal science of Marxism-Leninism` indeed I see it referenced so often that the cadres have developed a short hand version Diamat. And one of Stalin's most well known work is Dialectical and Historical Materialism. Which in addition to reciting quite a bit of Engels also extensively cites the works of Karl Marx. Now personally speaking I prefer Engels to Stalin, though I think Pannekoek's Historical Materialism was more compelling than both. But again if MLs published Marx's work and can even use it (misuse if you prefer) for their own purposes its obviously not the key to the problem.

The promotion of Karl Marx's stuff will probably help some people move away from the ML et al crowd, the Soviet Union was often the engine of communist and anarchist opposition to the Comintern and Trotskyism had a small resurgence in the ex USSR when people could read him instead of the official caricature. But that method works both ways, just as their are people who develop out of the official communist movement in ways that were more emancipatory and beneficial, but it can also work the other way around. The liberals were wrong when they argued that progress is linier, their are many examples of people with fairly solid politics finding more reactionary lines appealing. Fredy Pherlman and Cammatte became primitivists, Wildcat (I forget which one) also went in for primitivism. as well. The UK Class War have jumped all over in their history, Alex Schmidt became a racist, Christopher Hitchens went from a sort of Trotskyist to a Neocon culture warrior, I can keep going on but I think the point has been made.

The truth of the matter is that their are many variables for why someone finds something convincing or doesn't. A lot of people have turned the Manifesto into a sort of bible, I found it underwhelming. The Conquest of Bread is also enjoying popularity as an intro to anarchism, I liked it but I don't think it be enough to "convert" me. Quite a few MLs swear by State and Revolution and I think I've made my lack of enthusiasm on that one clear. It honestly worries me just how many people make this assumption, that someone who is not in agreement with you can't possibly have any clue what they're talking about. It exposes a rather unhealthy and to be frank snobbish world view and gives the impression of a stunted almost religious order style of education. Funnily enough given my chosen example its another thing the worst type of ML and Maoist parties actively cultivate within their organisations. 

In the UK the Ragged Trousered  Philanthropists is cited as being the moment of revelation for many British leftists of various persuasions, and I count myself as one of them. I also remember Lenin crediting Maxim Gorki's Mother for the popularity of socialism in the Russian underground*, Marx's Capital made such an impact on Bakunin that he started translating it into Russian, Hyndman a Conservative was inspired by the manifesto and a novel about the life and death of  Lassalle to found the Social Democratic Federation, described as the first Marxist political party in Britain. He would then go onto lead the ominously named National Socialist Party and then affiliate it with the Labour party.

My personal favourite example of political inspiration is the Communist Party USA member and former Soviet Spy Whittaker Chambers, who became a committed anti communist because he looked into his daughters ear. That seems ridiculous and maybe it is but the reasoning is honestly hard to argue with if you accept its main premise. 


 Whittaker Chambers in his seismic book Witness recounts the first moment when he abandoned historical materialism, mentally deserted the Communist cause, and embarked on the career which would undo Stalinism in America. It was on the morning when he glimpsed the ear of his baby daughter. The pretty whorls and folds of this external organ persuaded him in a flash of revelation that no coincidence could have created it. A fleshly flap of such utter beauty must be divine.
To break it down,

  • The complexity of the human ear is convincing for the proof of God
  • The party taught that God does not exist, so the Party is wrong
  • If it is wrong about that, than it could be wrong about many things, potentially everything
  • If it is wrong than the sacrifices made in its name are unjust
  • If it is unjust than it must be opposed 


Its easy to laugh at the power of an ear, but Whittaker was a successful spy and then a successful journalist so he wasn't a fool. And to be honest the faith Whittaker put into that ear is the same many of us put into our key texts. When we say `read _____` we're often just saying `come get a look at this ear` and hoping for a similar result. Its a bit of a crutch.




___________________________________________________________________________
*Unfortunately I've not been able to find the reference since. I remember it because that was how I discover the novel Mother








Friday, 4 May 2018

The Big Parade - Chen Kaige



"Build a new Great wall with our flesh and blood"


The Big Parade, directed by Chen Kaige was filmed and released in 1986. Its been overlooked and forgotten partly thanks to the success Chen Kaige enjoyed for some of his other films such as Yellow Earth. However at the time of its relese it caused quite a stir in both domestic and foreign circles. During the early years of Deng Xiaoping coming to power there was a loosening of control on what could and could not be shown in the media in the People's Republic. Unfortunately by the time The Big Parade was finished that period had ended and the state censors were not happy with the first cut.

The national commitment to economic reform made in 1979 by Deng Xiaoping resulted in a gradual expansion of the permissible. Literary journals sprang up in every city and province, publishing short stories and poems, most of them by unknown writers. Painters abandoned the artificial realism that party ideologues seemed most comfortable with in favor of more abstract and impressionistic works. Movie makers began to explore China's troubled recent past, including the violent politics of the decade long Cultural Revolution. Journalists uncovered widespread corruption within the Communist Party at local levels.
 But now, eight years later, China's best thinkers, its most talented film makers and painters, its experimental writers and poets are once again silent. Some university students have been jailed for demonstrating in support of ''freedom'' and ''democracy.'' Some intellectuals have lost their jobs, others have been imprisoned. Whether the student demonstrations touched off the crackdown or whether party hard-liners used the protests as a pretext for disciplining intellectuals and restricting their creativity remains an unanswered question.

They carried out some pretty extensive reshooting and editing. Most effected was the ending which is one of the most obvious and blatant edits I've ever seen. Sadly the initial reception from foreign critics was also poor, probably thanks to the heavy handed reworking the film was seen as just another in a long line of forgettable PRC propaganda films and aside from some criticism of its supposed themes the film was forgotten.

Though when news of how the film was made gave it a bit more recognition, its still pretty obscure outside of China.



The plot is incredibly minimal, a People's Liberation Army (PLA) unit has been given the honour of taking part in a parade through Tiananmen square to celebrate the 35th anniversary of the founding of the People's Republic of China.   

Thanks to that honour they are forced to undergo a gruelling drill regimen, nine kilometre runs through countryside including river crossing and ridge climbing, constant pace measuring and the stand to attention tests. If you've never had the pleasure of doing drill before that sounds pretty benign and easy, just stand still for a bit and look smart. Here they have to stand still for three hours on a concrete walkway in the baking sun. They have no shade and its so dangerous that a full medical team has to be on standby ready to respond to the men who collapse and vomit. When they aren't baking under the sun they're marching during torrential downpours. Its incredibly brutalising.

"From morning to night running, turning our heads each pace 1.2 metres, 116 steps a minute . Eyes up, eyes down, all together all the time,
One soldier Jiang Junbiao is bowlegged, in order to pass the drill tests he's taken to binding his legs every night, hoping it will straighten them. It doesn't work, if anything it makes him weaker, but he keeps on at it. This goes on for months, and at the end its revealed that the unit will march a mere 96 steps which will be less than a minute at their usual pace. They've marched just under 10,000 Km during training. To quote instructor Sun  "9,993 kilometres for a minute. Not just a matter of political principles."

I honestly can't read this in anyway other than criticism. At the end Sun gives a speech that's militaristic and patriotic propaganda about how great soldiers are and how important it is to serve the nation. But the content of his speech comes across as a dark joke, he compares what they went through to the Long March and recites his favourite lyrics from the national anthem "Build a new Great Wall with our flesh and blood" but then he lists what the men have undergone over the months of constant drilling. Including the time when a soldier didn't go home to his mothers funeral, and another soldier cried as they sent him away. He even documents the number of boots (four pairs each) worn out and how each man has used about six tonnes worth of boot nails. All for less than a minutes worth of screen time on the television. Its a complete waste.

Wednesday, 2 May 2018

1848 The Year of Revolutions


In 1848 political turmoil in the Italian states and the collapse of the July Monarchy in France and the establishment of the Second French Republic encouraged liberals, nationalists, republicans of all types and the young Socialist movement in much of Europe to rally. Revolutionary outbreaks occurred throughout the rest of Italy, much of the German states including Prussia and the city of Baden, the Hapsburg Empire was tearing itself apart at the seems with Hungarians pushing for autonomy and then independence, the workers and students of Vienna rising up and chasing the Emperor out of his capital, the Italian possesions in revolt, with Venice withstand Austrian bombardment and siege for months, and the building of barricades in Prague.

Elsewhere the revolutions made themselves felt, Denmark, fearing the revolution would spread from Prussia passed extensive political reforms, and in Ireland an armed uprising of the Young Irish threatened British rule.

This video is a discussion by various academics on the extent of the revolts and the impact and legacy of those movements.



Melvyn Bragg and his guests discuss 1848, the year that saw Europe engulfed in revolution. Across the continent, from Paris to Palermo, liberals rose against conservative governments. The first stirrings of rebellion came in January, in Sicily; in February the French monarchy fell; and within a few months Germany, Austria, Hungary and Italy had all been overtaken by revolutionary fervour. Only a few countries, notably Britain and Russia, were spared.The rebels were fighting for nationalism, social justice and civil rights, and were prepared to fight in the streets down to the last man. Tens of thousands of people lost their lives; but little of lasting value was achieved, and by the end of the year the liberal revolutions had been soundly beaten.With: Tim BlanningEmeritus Professor of History at the University of CambridgeLucy RiallProfessor of History at Birkbeck, University of LondonMike RapportSenior Lecturer in History at the University of Stirling.Producer: Thomas Morris.

 I've been slowly building up an archive of the revolts on Libcom.org, so far focusing on the events in Germany and France.

Friday, 27 April 2018

Two


TWO

Light.

There was lightness, seen from the inside of a cloud, white light that came from all directions, somehow came from inside him as well as out, and he opened his eyes.

The white light did not go away, grew more intense with his eyes open.
`Can you feel this?` Somebody pinched his legs and it hurt. He swore.
`That is good. Move something now, move this foot…`
the boy started to focus and saw that what he thought was white light was really the shirt of the old man reflecting the glare from the bulb hanging in the shed where they slept.

He moved his foot then his hands and arms, each as he was told to move, and at last his neck. By now an older woman – at least forty – was there and she said something in Spanish and felt his neck and shoulders, then smiled at him with even white teeth and said something more.

`She says you are young and green and did not break,` the old man said. `I thought surely a bone or two would have snapped. You fell such a distance,` he laughed, `and even when you were senseless you did not let go of the pigeon.` He smiled. `You must be a true hunter.`

Which made the boy feel proud because he had hunted, had thrown himself at the woods to escape the drinking and fancied himself a good hunter. `I hurt.`

`As you should. The ground shook when you fell. But it will be worse tomorrow when you awaken – you must sleep now.`

The boy rolled onto his side and then rose to his knees. He did not want to appear weak in front of the old man or the woman kneeling next to him or the two girls standing off to the side, so he stood, wobbling, and made his way to his sleeping area and fell onto his bed of feed sacks and was asleep, or unconscious again, instantly.

In the morning he thought, I am paralysed. He had slept on his right side, a rolled-up feed sack for a pillow, and he had drooled and his head was pressed into the wetness. He wanted to move it away but he could not.

His body screamed with pain. Every bone, every muscle, his head, even his teeth, ached and when at last he made something move – he swung his leg sideways – it was pure agony.

He rolled slowly onto his back and opened his eyes. There was daylight, bright sun, cutting into the gloom of the shed and he knew that he was very late – it must be close to nine – and that all the Mexicans were gone to the fields and would get so far ahead of him he would never catch up. In his life he would never catch up, he thought, and then he saw the farmer’s wife come in the door.

His sleeping area was way in the back of the shed, tucked in a dark corner so that somebody coming in from the bright sun would not be able to see to the rear where he lay. He held his breath, watching her, wondering.

She wore a loose red-print dress that hung on her like a drape. She stopped at the first bed on the left side – the men slept on the left, the women on the right – and reached down to pull a sack up from the floor. She held the sack in her left hand and put it to her face, her cheek, and then to her nose and smelled it and breathed the odour of the sack and at the same time she slid her other hand down her body.

The boy forgot the pain and felt him self grow hard and at the same time confused because she had said she hated the Mexicans and didn’t want the men to get her and yet here she was breathing in the smell of them.

Popular Posts